Explore Homes for Sale in Hill City, SD

Map Search for Hill City, SD Homes for Sale

Discover Homes for Sale in Hill City, South Dakota

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Explore the diverse range of homes for sale in Hill City, SD, a charming town nestled in the heart of the Black Hills. Find your dream property, from cozy cabins to spacious family homes, with Pioneer Properties SD, Adam Johnson RE. Discover the perfect blend of small-town living and outdoor adventure.

Search Hill City, SD by Lifestyle
Search Hill City, SD by Price
Search Hill City, SD by Bedrooms
Search Hill City, SD by Bathrooms

Exploring Hill City Real Estate

The Appeal of Hill City Homes

Hill City offers a unique real estate market, characterized by its proximity to natural beauty and a strong sense of community. The homes for sale reflect the area's character, ranging from rustic retreats to modern residences. As you consider your options, take into account the varying styles and locations that contribute to Hill City's distinct appeal.

Understanding the Local Market

Navigating the real estate market in Hill City requires an understanding of the local nuances. Factors such as proximity to recreational areas, lot size, and home style can all influence property values. Therefore, careful consideration of these aspects is essential in your home search. Pioneer Properties SD, Adam Johnson RE is here to help you navigate all options.

Finding Your Ideal Home

Types of Homes Available

The selection of homes for sale in Hill City encompasses a variety of styles and sizes. Whether you are seeking a secluded cabin, a family-friendly house, or a low-maintenance condo, you'll find options to suit your needs. So, begin exploring the available properties and envision your life in this vibrant community.

Lifestyle Considerations

Choosing a home is not just about the property itself, but also about the lifestyle it offers. Hill City provides a wealth of outdoor activities, cultural events, and a welcoming atmosphere. Therefore, consider how your home will complement your lifestyle and preferences.

The Home Buying Process in Hill City

Working with a Real Estate Professional

The home buying process can be complex, but working with an experienced real estate professional can simplify the experience. A local agent can provide valuable insights, guide you through negotiations, and help you find the perfect home for sale in Hill City. Pioneer Properties SD, Adam Johnson RE are the local experts.

Financing Your Home Purchase

Securing financing is a crucial step in the home buying process. Explore your mortgage options and work with a lender to determine your budget. Therefore, pre-approval can strengthen your offer and demonstrate your commitment to purchasing a home.

Newest Homes for Sale in Hill City, SD

$1,299,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 89371 MLS
EXTRAORDINARY BLACK HILLS BEAUTY! This jaw-dropping home is bursting at the seams with amenities! Nestled on a small acreage almost completely surrounded by miles upon miles of USFS land! Spend a lifetime exploring! Open & covered decks all around the home that beckon you to sit a spell & soak in the sights & sounds of this serene setting. Wildlife abounds! Eat-in kitchen, stainless steel appliances, pantry, a center island w/ cooktop & built-in wine rack. The kitchen opens up to a grand dining area & vast living room w/ sky-high wood vaulted ceiling, floor-to-ceiling window display & stone-encased wood-burning stove. Main level also holds a sizeable bedroom & bath. Stone-lined winding staircase leads up to a spacious loft highlighting a luxurious master suite w/ whirlpool tub, walk-in closet w/ laundry, double vanity & private water closet. Even more space abounds in the basement, w/ a nice sized family room w/ lovely brick fireplace, 3rd & 4th ample bedrooms, 3rd bath, small kitchenette, plus a bonus room. Heaps of space on the massive decks that overlook the nature residing just out the windows. There is a 12x20 detached garage/shed plus an ENORMOUS SHOP featuring insulation, electricity, plumbing & concrete floor. Tuck-under 2-stall garage. Cozy firepit area, hot tub & partially fenced-in yard. Brimming w/ pine trees & panoramic Hills views as far as the eye can see - want for nothing! Currently used as a vacation rental. Please plan ahead for showings.

22734 S Rochford Road, Hill City
$219,000
179837 MLS
Don't let the name fool you—there's nothing "Dead Broke" about this spectacular Black Hills property. Sweeping views, Spring Creek meandering just below, horses welcome, and the Mickelson Trail just beyond your property make this 3.42-acre parcel a rare opportunity just minutes from Hill City, known as the Heart of the Black Hills. Whether you envision a walkout home that maximizes the natural topography or prefer to build on the level area near the existing shed, this property offers exceptional flexibility to bring your build to life. Towering ponderosa pines, abundant wildlife, and long-range views create the quintessential Black Hills setting. Step outside to enjoy horseback riding, hiking, biking, or evening walks along one of the region's most scenic recreational corridors, the Mickelson Trail. Conveniently located just minutes from Hill City's restaurants, shopping, wineries, breweries, art galleries, and year-round events, you'll also be centrally located to Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park, Sheridan Lake, and Pactola Reservoir. Paved highway access (and a very short gravel road) provide easy year-round travel while preserving the privacy and tranquility of this wooded retreat. Light covenants allow for site-built, modular, and manufactured homes, giving you the freedom to create the Black Hills getaway—or full-time residence—you've always imagined. Covenants appear to have expired.

TBD Deadbroke Rd Tbd Dead Broke Rd, Hill City
$219,000
89350 MLS
Don't let the name fool you—there's nothing "Dead Broke" about this spectacular Black Hills property. Sweeping views, Spring Creek meandering just below, horses welcome, and the Mickelson Trail just beyond your property make this 3.42-acre parcel a rare opportunity just minutes from Hill City, known as the Heart of the Black Hills. Whether you envision a walkout home that maximizes the natural topography or prefer to build on the level area near the existing shed, this property offers exceptional flexibility to bring your build to life. Towering ponderosa pines, abundant wildlife, and long-range views create the quintessential Black Hills setting. Step outside to enjoy horseback riding, hiking, biking, or evening walks along one of the region's most scenic recreational corridors, the Mickelson Trail. Conveniently located just minutes from Hill City's restaurants, shopping, wineries, breweries, art galleries, and year-round events, you'll also be centrally located to Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park, Sheridan Lake, and Pactola Reservoir. Paved highway access (and a very short gravel road) provide easy year-round travel while preserving the privacy and tranquility of this wooded retreat. Light covenants allow for site-built, modular, and manufactured homes, giving you the freedom to create the Black Hills getaway—or full-time residence—you've always imagined. Covenants have expired and seller says no covenants.

TBD Deadbroke Road, Hill City
$399,900
3 Beds ⋅ 179708 MLS
If you've ever dreamed of owning a rare creekside property, this is your opportunity! This 3-bedroom home is full of potential and sits on 1.89 beautiful acres in the highly desirable Hill City, South Dakota. The property features an oversized two-car garage plus an additional 15' x 9.5' storage shed with electricity, providing plenty of space for hobbies, storage, or projects. There are also 2 storage sheds as well. The location couldn't be better—just off Highway 16, offering breathtaking views in every direction while maintaining the peaceful setting you've been looking for. Imagine stepping outside your front door to fish, relax, or simply enjoy the sights and sounds of the creek flowing through your own property. With nearly two acres, there's also plenty of room to build the dream shop or additional outbuilding you've always wanted. Properties like this don't come along often. Come experience the beauty, tranquility, and endless possibilities of this one-of-a-kind Hill City retreat

12662 Robins Roost Rd, Hill City
$1,450,150
179674 MLS
Listed with Jill VantHul 605-593-3242 and TJ Wojtanowicz 605-863-1920 at Black Hills Realty. This is your chance to own the legendary Bumpin Buffalo Bar & Grill on Main Street in Hill City. With its unique rooftop deck, this property offers history, nostalgia and sentimentality that appeals to all ages. This rare opportunity combines rustic charm and a turn key investment with immense potential. Currently operating seasonally from early May through October, the property has shown consistent growth and presents a clear opportunity to extend operations into the shoulder seasons OR even year-round, the Bumpin Buffalo shows consistent receipts with an opportunity to continue this trend. The current owners have successfully operated the property for 9 years and are ready to pass it along to its next owners and their vision for its future.

245 Main, Hill City
$1,450,150
89225 MLS
Listed with Jill VantHul 605-593-3242 and TJ Wojtanowicz 605-863-1920 at Black Hills Realty. This is your chance to own the legendary Bumpin Buffalo Bar & Grill on Main Street in Hill City. With its unique rooftop deck, this property offers history, nostalgia and sentimentality that appeals to all ages. This rare opportunity combines rustic charm and a turn key investment with immense potential. Currently operating seasonally from early May through October, the property has shown consistent growth and presents a clear opportunity to extend operations into the shoulder seasons OR even year-round, the Bumpin Buffalo shows consistent receipts with an opportunity to continue this trend. The current owners have successfully operated the property for 8 years and are ready to pass it along to its next owners and their vision for its future.

245 Main Street, Hill City
$1,450,150
179673 MLS
Listed with Jill VantHul 605-593-3242 and TJ Wojtanowicz 605-863-1920 at Black Hills Realty. This is your chance to own the legendary Bumpin Buffalo Bar & Grill on Main Street in Hill City. With its unique rooftop deck, this property offers history, nostalgia and sentimentality that appeals to all ages. This rare opportunity combines rustic charm and a turn key investment with immense potential. Currently operating seasonally from early May through October, the property has shown consistent growth and presents a clear opportunity to extend operations into the shoulder seasons OR even year-round, the Bumpin Buffalo shows consistent receipts with an opportunity to continue this trend. The current owners have successfully operated the property for 8 years and are ready to pass it along to its next owners and their vision for its future.

245 Main, Hill City
$675,000
2 Beds ⋅ 179582 MLS
Listed by Stuart Martin, Re/Max Results 605-390-4227. Experience the beauty of the Black Hills in this custom-built Hill City retreat, perfectly situated on 6.32 scenic acres with breathtaking views. Designed for comfortable one-level living, this 1,524 sq. ft. home features an open-concept floor plan with vaulted ceilings, luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, and ceramic tile in the bathrooms. The stunning kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing rustic alder cabinetry with soft-close doors and drawers, live-edge granite countertops, black stainless steel appliances, and an oversized pantry. A formal dining area and spacious breakfast bar provide ample seating for entertaining family and friends. A pellet stove in the living room adds warmth and ambiance during the cooler months. The home offers two bedrooms, including a private primary suite with patio access, a walk-in closet, and a beautifully appointed bathroom featuring dual vanities and a custom-tiled walk-in shower. Step outside and enjoy the Black Hills year-round from the impressive 14' x 35' stamped concrete patio, complete with a tongue-and-groove ceiling and incredible hilltop views. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or a peaceful getaway, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort, quality, and natural beauty. Don't miss your opportunity to own this exceptional Black Hills retreat—contact your favorite REALTOR® today to schedule a showing!

611 Forest St, Hill City
$777,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 89121 MLS
EXCEPTIONAL NEW CONSTRUCTION BARNDO on almost 6 acres, framed by an awe-inspiring Elkhorn Range view! Ideally located just off paved Old Hill City Rd, this property offers a true sense of retreat, yet just 2 miles to Hill City—right in the heart of everything the Black Hills have to offer. Nearly 1200 sq. ft. of NEWLY finished, open, bright living space, thoughtfully designed & enhanced w/quality upgrades throughout. Energy-efficiency is top of mind w/R29 insulation in the walls & R48 in the ceiling, helping maintain year-round livability. Massive attached garage/shop space is a standout feature, complete w/3 garage doors—including a 12-ft door easily accommodating a full-size RV. Wood accents on walls & portions of the ceiling, while a large utility/storage room includes an on-demand H2O heater & softener. Buried 1,000-gallon propane tank is already in place. Infrastructure is already dialed in for future expansion, including a 500-ft deep well producing 30 GPM w/static level of 60 ft, along w/the largest septic system installed to accommodate up to a 5-bed home. Outdoor opportunity abounds w/road leading to the hilltop where another potential building site awaits. Surrounded by beauty, privacy & abundant USFS lands. Perfectly positioned for hiking, exploring, hunting & riding. Quality construction, thoughtful planning, and unbeatable location—this is one you truly need to see in person!

12584 Mills Ranch Road, Hill City
$699,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 89120 MLS
WHERE WILDERNESS, WATER & WONDER COLLIDE! Perched high on a hillside overlooking breathtaking scenery, this captivating octagon home offers the ultimate private retreat w/SPECTACULAR VIEWS & S. Rapid Creek flowing below! At the heart of this one-of-a-kind home is a stunning octagonal atrium featuring exposed beams & whimsical spiral staircase centerpiece. Thoughtfully-designed main level radiates from the atrium, leading to a spacious master bed, office, entry/laundry area & charming kitchen. Basement mirrors the unique design above, offering an expansive family/recreation room, large additional bed & ample storage/utility space. While the spiral staircase adds timeless character, the walkout basement provides convenient access. Strong-producing well, reverse osmosis water system & high-speed internet. A nearly new Morton building provides exceptional space for an RV, workshop, vehicles & recreational toys, complete w/mezzanine level for extra storage. Cast a line in the creek right on your own property or explore the endless surrounding public lands. Located just 2 miles from the charming community of Rochford, enjoy easy access to the famous Moonshine Gulch Saloon, the Mickelson Trail & the small-town charm that makes this area so special. Surrounded by some of the most unspoiled public lands, this is a gateway to year-round adventure, including hiking, horseback riding, ATVing, hunting, fishing, wildlife watching & more. This is truly a special Black Hills package.

11504 Melchert Place, Hill City
$730,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 89090 MLS
Perched atop 4.31 acres with sweeping Black Hills views, this beautifully updated chalet-style home offers the peace, privacy, and scenery that make the Hills so special. Located just 3 miles from Deerfield Reservoir and a short drive to Hill City, you'll enjoy easy access to fishing, hiking, hunting, snowmobiling, ATV trails, and National Forest recreation. Built in 2016 and expanded with a 1,000+ sq. ft. addition, this 2,900 sq. ft. home features 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, three walk-in closets, a walk-in pantry, and large windows that fill the home with natural light while showcasing views that include Harney Peak. The spacious primary suite offers dual walk-in closets, a laundry chute, and a beautifully tiled walk-in shower. The guest bathroom is designed for relaxation with a steam shower and jetted tub. Recent updates include a new roof with Class 4 impact-resistant shingles (2022) and LP SmartSide siding on both the home and detached shop (2023). The home is heated with Cove electric heat and supplemented by a pellet stove. Starlink internet and a Lorex security camera system are included. The attached two-car garage provides additional workspace and storage, while the detached 26x32 shop features insulation, concrete floors, electricity and an insulated barn-style door. Outside you'll also find a greenhouse, pergola, raised planters, horseshoe pit, and a dedicated spa location complete with electrical service and hot water hookup. Spectacular sunrises! 605-891-1298

23391 J Range Ct., Hill City
$499,900
4 Beds ⋅ 179430 MLS
Listed by Mark Veley 605-484-8170 with South Dakota Properties. Welcome to your home in the Black Hills! Whether you are looking for something year-round or a retreat this beautiful 4-bedroom, 3-bath home with a spacious oversized 2-car garage, ideally situated in a quiet neighborhood with minimal traffic. Enjoy amazing views from the living room and family room windows as well as the walk out basement patio. The large deck, backyard and side yard with patio are perfect for relaxing and entertaining. This fully finished, move-in ready home features a wide-open floor plan, insulated taped textured painted garage, modern finishes, beautiful solid surface countertops, and a large oversized lower-level family room. A perfect blend of comfort, style, and functionality! Don’t miss the chance to make this exceptional property your new home in one of the area’s most beloved neighborhoods! *Landscaping is added for visual effect. Owner is a licensed realtor

910 Top O' Hill Ave, Hill City
Start Your Search