Explore Homes for Sale in Custer, SD

Map Search for Custer, SD Homes for Sale

Discover Homes for Sale in Custer, South Dakota

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Explore the diverse selection of homes for sale in Custer, SD, a charming town nestled in the heart of the Black Hills. Pioneer Properties SD, with Adam Johnson RE, is your trusted partner in finding the perfect property to call home in this beautiful region. From cozy cabins to spacious family residences, Custer offers a range of real estate opportunities to suit every lifestyle and budget.

Search Custer, SD by Lifestyle
Search Custer, SD by Price
Search Custer, SD by Bedrooms
Search Custer, SD by Bathrooms

Exploring Real Estate Opportunities in Custer

Custer, South Dakota, presents a unique blend of small-town charm and access to breathtaking natural landscapes. As you consider homes for sale, understanding the local market and the various neighborhoods is key to finding the right fit. We can help with that.

Finding Your Ideal Property

The process of searching for homes for sale can be exciting, and it's essential to consider your priorities. Are you looking for a property with acreage, a modern home in town, or a historic residence with character? Defining your needs and desires will streamline your search and ensure you find a home that truly meets your expectations.

The Allure of Custer Living

Living in Custer offers a quality of life that is hard to match. The surrounding Black Hills provide endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, from hiking and biking to fishing and wildlife viewing. Furthermore, the town itself boasts a vibrant arts scene, local shops, and a strong sense of community.

Navigating the Home Buying Process

Purchasing a home is a significant investment, and understanding the process is crucial. From securing financing to negotiating an offer, being prepared can help ensure a smooth and successful transaction. Consider working with a local realtor from Pioneer Properties SD for guidance.

Financing Your Dream Home

Before beginning your home search, it's wise to explore your financing options. Getting pre-approved for a mortgage will give you a clear understanding of your budget and strengthen your position when making an offer on a home for sale.

Making an Offer and Closing the Deal

Once you've found the perfect home, the next step is to make an offer. Your realtor can help you craft a competitive offer that reflects the current market conditions and your desired terms. After the offer is accepted, the closing process involves inspections, appraisals, and finalizing the paperwork to transfer ownership.

The Beauty of Custer: A Place to Call Home

With its stunning scenery, friendly community, and diverse real estate options, Custer is a truly special place to call home. We invite you to explore the homes for sale and discover the unique charm and opportunities that await you in this beautiful corner of South Dakota.

Newest Homes for Sale in Custer, SD

$112,500
89170 MLS
RARE OPPORTUNITY to own just over 2 acres in the highly sought-after Caledonia Estates subdivision, just outside of Custer! Beautifully covered with mature pine trees, this private lot adjoins USFS land, offering direct access to thousands of acres of Black Hills National Forest for hiking, horseback riding, wildlife viewing & endless outdoor recreation. Enjoy the perfect balance of seclusion & convenience, with electricity & high-speed fiber internet available at the lot line. Established homes throughout the subdivision, spacious 2–5 acre parcels & light protective covenants help maintain the area's appeal & long-term value. Priced below current market value, this property stands out in today's limited inventory of 2–3 acre lots! Located just 15 minutes from Custer, you'll enjoy easy access to shopping, dining, healthcare, and everyday amenities while remaining close to some of the Black Hills' most treasured destinations. Minutes from Custer State Park, Stockade Lake & the Mickelson Trail. Nearby attractions include Jewel Cave, Crazy Horse Memorial, Wind Cave National Park, Mount Rushmore & countless recreational opportunities! If you've been searching for a private Black Hills retreat with National Forest access, scenic surroundings, and a premier location, this property deserves a closer look!

TBD Caledonia Trail, Custer
$334,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 89162 MLS
Absolute CREAM OF THE CROP investment opportunity! Upgraded throughout, turnkey, fully furnished vacation rental in CITY LIMITS on a treed near half acre in a private, end of the road location! Adorable 2 bed 1.5 bath home has fully remodeled & revamped kitchen with lots of countertop space, plenty of cabinets, and matching appliances. Great sized formal dining room. Hub of the home, wood adorned living room with cozy brick encased wood burning fireplace, built-in shelves, and vaulted ceiling. Handy half bathroom rounds out the main floor. 2 huge upstairs bedrooms and updated full bathroom. Oversized attached 1 stall garage doubles as a bonus/game room. Enjoy peace and quiet on the cute covered porch. This perfect location is walking distance to Custer's downtown strip for great food and shopping. Experience all the Black Hills have to offer! Vacation rental license will transfer with sale to new owner, call City of Custer Planning for more information. Cute as can be, every box is checked! Schedule your showing today!

241 N 4th Street, Custer
$499,000
179605 MLS
Creekside! An extremely rare offering in the Black Hills. This exceptional 10-acre property off Lower French Creek Road features no covenants, French Creek meandering through the north end, and is surrounded on three sides by U.S. Forest Service land, creating recreation, privacy and natural beauty. French Creek is one of the Black Hills' most beloved waterways, known for its scenic beauty, wildlife habitat, and fishing opportunities. With multiple potential building sites, the property is ready for your vision. Existing improvements include a well, septic system, and electric service already established at a primary build site. Additional electric service is available on the west end of the property, where a metal carport and RV setup with 30, 50-amp, and 110 hookups provide a convenient basecamp while you plan and build. A second RV pedestal with matching service was recently installed near the well. The previous A-frame cabin was lost in the Qury Fire, creating a blank canvas and a rare opportunity to design your ideal Black Hills retreat. Extensive cleanup has already been completed, including removal of fire debris and significant tree mitigation. Enjoy the sounds of the creek, abundant wildlife, towering pines, and direct access to thousands of acres of National Forest from your own property. Opportunities combining live water, existing infrastructure, no covenants, and U.S. Forest Service boundaries are exceptionally rare in today's market.

25287 Lower French Creek Rd, Custer
$259,000
3 Beds ⋅ 179604 MLS
There's something special about a turn-of-the-century home in an established Custer neighborhood. Mature trees, mountain views, and a location within walking distance of downtown, the hospital, and the Mickelson Trail make this charming bungalow a standout opportunity. Recent updates include a new roof, new water heater, newer appliances and fresh paint. There's also a radon mitigation system for added peace of mind. The large fenced backyard provides plenty of space for pets, gardening, and outdoor enjoyment. Sellers especially love the views of Buckhorn Mountain from the back of the home, the easy access to the Mickelson Trail, and the room to grow flowers and vegetables. A storage shed offers space for tools, lawn equipment, and gardening supplies. Low-maintenance metal siding, mature shade trees and a convenient circular driveway and a beautiful back patio add to the home's appeal. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, retirement home or investment property, this affordable Custer property is worth a look.

821 Montgomery, Custer
$499,000
89157 MLS
Creekside! An extremely rare offering in the Black Hills. This exceptional 10-acre property off Lower French Creek Road features no covenants, French Creek meandering through the north end, and is surrounded on three sides by U.S. Forest Service land, creating recreation, privacy and natural beauty. French Creek is one of the Black Hills' most beloved waterways, known for its scenic beauty, wildlife habitat, and fishing opportunities. With multiple potential building sites, the property is ready for your vision. Existing improvements include a well, septic system, and electric service already established at a primary build site. Additional electric service is available on the west end of the property, where a metal carport and RV setup with 30, 50-amp, and 110 hookups provide a convenient basecamp while you plan and build. A second RV pedestal with matching service was recently installed near the well. The previous A-frame cabin was lost in the Qury Fire, creating a blank canvas and a rare opportunity to design your ideal Black Hills retreat. Extensive cleanup has already been completed, including removal of fire debris and significant tree mitigation. Enjoy the sounds of the creek, abundant wildlife, towering pines, and direct access to thousands of acres of National Forest from your own property. Opportunities combining live water, existing infrastructure, no covenants, and U.S. Forest Service boundaries are exceptionally rare in today's market.

25287 Lower French Creek Road, Custer
$259,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 89149 MLS
There's something special about a turn-of-the-century home in an established Custer neighborhood. Mature trees, mountain views, and a location within walking distance of downtown, the hospital, and the Mickelson Trail make this charming bungalow a standout opportunity. Recent updates include a new roof, new water heater, newer appliances and fresh paint. There's also a radon mitigation system for added peace of mind. The large fenced backyard provides plenty of space for pets, gardening, and outdoor enjoyment. Sellers especially love the views of Buckhorn Mountain from the back of the home, the easy access to the Mickelson Trail, and the room to grow flowers and vegetables. A storage shed offers space for tools, lawn equipment, and gardening supplies. Low-maintenance metal siding, mature shade trees and a convenient circular driveway add to the home's appeal. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, retirement home or investment property, this affordable Custer property is worth a look.

821 Montgomery Street, Custer
$619,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 89115 MLS
CUSTOM BUILD NESTLED IN THE WOODS, FULLY-FURNISHED, TURNKEY & ENHANCED WITH LOT OF UPGRADES! Convenient main-level living in this top quality ranch-style home, crafted by the highly respected Studt Construction on just over 4 ac! Owner has invested approximately $40-50K in recent upgrades & improvements over the past few months. Warm & welcoming kitchen showcases hickory cabinets, Hi-Mac solid surface countertops & walk-in pantry. Comfortable living room centers around a cozy propane FP. Relaxing master bed w/full bath, as well as 2nd bed & bath. Laundry room offers utility sink, generous counter space, custom cabinets & storage closet. Attached garage w/220V heater & storage space, a carport, storage shed, generator shed w/generator, spacious deck & inviting firepit areas. Class 4 high-impact resistant roof, designed for superior durability & potential insurance savings, offering added protection in SD's hail-prone climate. Unique bonus is the lower lot w/electric RV hookup & offers an ideal location for a shop, guest house, or second residence. Towering pines & stunning granite outcroppings make it feel like your own private park. Just a short walk from USFS land, enjoy immediate access to hiking, wildlife viewing & endless outdoor recreation. There are vacation rentals in the neighborhood. If you've been searching for a well-built, thoughtfully maintained Black Hills retreat w/recent upgrades, privacy & room to grow, this exceptional property deserves your attention!

11754 Caledonia Trail, Custer
$1,249,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 88996 MLS
THIS IS A MUST-SEE PROPERTY!! Originally built by the Kirk Brothers as a dairy barn in 1886 and then reimaged into a residential property that must be seen to be totally appreciated. The workmanship that went into the transformation from a dairy barn to a luxurious home is unbelievable. Painstaking attention to detail. The features of this home are too many to completely mention but include 4 bedrooms with 5 full bathrooms. Original hand-hewn posts and beams, mortis and tenon joints, hand crafted white oak woodwork and cabinetry, an impressive 27' stacked stone fireplace hearth, and countless other details. Relax and enjoy a cup of coffee or a glass of wine in the sunken seating area, in front of the 2-story wood-burning fireplace or on the expansive back deck that offers a wonderful outdoor living space. A chef's dream kitchen on one end of the home has custom cabinetry, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, a large walk-in pantry and coffee bar. Main floor master suite option on far end of the home with a large bedroom with 2 closets and an ensuite bath. Upstairs there is a 2nd level balcony that overlooks the living room and gives wrap around access to all the upper-level bedrooms.

11892 Katherine Court, Custer
$775,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 88982 MLS
Turn-Key Black Hills Property with Proven VRBO Potential! Located just outside the Custer city limits, this exceptional property offers the perfect combination of privacy, flexibility, and income potential with no covenants and a successful history as a vacation rental (VRBO). Situated on 2.5 picturesque acres in a park-like setting, this spacious property features over 2,500 square feet of living space with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, providing plenty of room for family, guests, or rental visitors. The impressive outbuildings set this property apart, including a 24' x 32' attached garage and an enormous 54' x 60' shop complete with large overhead doors, a seperate 20x15' shop in the shop with concrete flooirng, offering ample space for RV storage, recreational vehicles, equipment, hobbies, or a home-based business. The property also benefits from a county-maintained road district, ensuring year-round accessibility. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a Black Hills getaway, or an investment property with an established rental history, this turn-key property offers endless possibilities, abundant storage, and a peaceful setting just minutes from all the amenities and attractions of Custer. No covenants. Proven VRBO history. RV storage. Spacious shop. Black Hills living at its best! Listed by Lori Svoboda and Glenna Johnson, owner/brokers at Western Skies Real Estate.

12359 Moss Rock Lane, Custer
$109,500
88934 MLS
Stone Hill Subdivision has beautiful lots available with amazing views of the Needles! Walking distance to Custer schools, tennis courts, mickelson trail and downtown Custer! Buy now and build later! These lots offer city water & sewer on site, underground electricity and fiber optics through Golden West. Now is the time to own your piece of dirt in the beautiful Black Hills. No modulars allowed on lots off Park Ave. List price of lots are NOT negotiable Listed with Lori Svoboda @ Western Skies Real Estate in Custer 605+517--0785

Lot 22 Block 1 Park Avenue, Custer
$245,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 88933 MLS
GREAT IMPROVED PRICE!! Perfect investment!!! Looking for the perfect location near Big Rock Park? Want a home you can truly design & update to fit your own style and needs? Then 1118 Canal St may be exactly what you’ve been searching for! This 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home sits on a spacious and private .34-acre lot that offers endless possibilities for customization and added value. The home features an enclosed breezeway connecting to the attached oversized 2-stall garage, complete with a 20x22 loft area above — ideal for storage, hobbies, or workshop space. Inside, you’ll find: A large foyer that could easily serve as a home office or flex space, an inviting living room with a charming fireplace full of character, large unfinished attic space for additional storage. The spacious basement family room has a wood stove, separate game room with collapsible table, 11x6 storage area, a nonconforming bedroom and bathroom/laundry area. Two separate basement entrances for added convenience and flexibility. This home offers incredible potential & room to grow, though it does need updating — making it the perfect opportunity to create the home you’ve always wanted while staying within budget. Bring your creativity and make this property your own! MLS# 88933 Offered at just $245,000. Call or Text Anne Fuchs at 605-673-1177 for more information or to schedule a viewing.

1118 Canal Street, Custer
$79,500
88932 MLS
Stone Hill Subdivision has beautiful lots available with amazing views of the Needles! Walking distance to Custer schools, tennis courts, mickelson trail and downtown Custer! Buy now and build later! These lots offer city water & sewer on site, underground electricity and fiber optics through Golden West. Now is the time to own your piece of dirt in the beautiful Black Hills. Covenants will allow modulars on certain lots with modifications and approval from the ACC. No modulars allowed on lots off Park Ave. List price of lots are NOT negotiable Listed with Lori Svoboda @ Western Skies Real Estate in Custer 605+517--0785

Lot 21 BLock 1 Stone Hill, Custer
Start Your Search