Explore Homes for Sale in Custer, SD

Map Search for Custer, SD Homes for Sale

Discover Homes for Sale in Custer, South Dakota

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Explore the diverse selection of homes for sale in Custer, SD, a charming town nestled in the heart of the Black Hills. Pioneer Properties SD, with Adam Johnson RE, is your trusted partner in finding the perfect property to call home in this beautiful region. From cozy cabins to spacious family residences, Custer offers a range of real estate opportunities to suit every lifestyle and budget.

Search Custer, SD by Lifestyle
Search Custer, SD by Price
Search Custer, SD by Bedrooms
Search Custer, SD by Bathrooms

Exploring Real Estate Opportunities in Custer

Custer, South Dakota, presents a unique blend of small-town charm and access to breathtaking natural landscapes. As you consider homes for sale, understanding the local market and the various neighborhoods is key to finding the right fit. We can help with that.

Finding Your Ideal Property

The process of searching for homes for sale can be exciting, and it's essential to consider your priorities. Are you looking for a property with acreage, a modern home in town, or a historic residence with character? Defining your needs and desires will streamline your search and ensure you find a home that truly meets your expectations.

The Allure of Custer Living

Living in Custer offers a quality of life that is hard to match. The surrounding Black Hills provide endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, from hiking and biking to fishing and wildlife viewing. Furthermore, the town itself boasts a vibrant arts scene, local shops, and a strong sense of community.

Navigating the Home Buying Process

Purchasing a home is a significant investment, and understanding the process is crucial. From securing financing to negotiating an offer, being prepared can help ensure a smooth and successful transaction. Consider working with a local realtor from Pioneer Properties SD for guidance.

Financing Your Dream Home

Before beginning your home search, it's wise to explore your financing options. Getting pre-approved for a mortgage will give you a clear understanding of your budget and strengthen your position when making an offer on a home for sale.

Making an Offer and Closing the Deal

Once you've found the perfect home, the next step is to make an offer. Your realtor can help you craft a competitive offer that reflects the current market conditions and your desired terms. After the offer is accepted, the closing process involves inspections, appraisals, and finalizing the paperwork to transfer ownership.

The Beauty of Custer: A Place to Call Home

With its stunning scenery, friendly community, and diverse real estate options, Custer is a truly special place to call home. We invite you to explore the homes for sale and discover the unique charm and opportunities that await you in this beautiful corner of South Dakota.

Newest Homes for Sale in Custer, SD

$228,480
87472 MLS
Extraordinary night skies and minimal light pollution. Discover the "Ultimate Black Hills Escape" at Desperado Ranch! This rare 8.17-acre parcel offers endless possibilities—from Barndominiums, modular or manufactured homes with sloped roofs and foundations, to RV parking, camping, B&Bs, and VRBOs. Enjoy a beautiful building site with Rural water tap fee paid, electricity available, fiber optic connectivity, and easy access to HWY 89. Prime Location only minutes from the Mickelson Trail and the National Forest Service, with Custer and Hot Springs only 16 miles away. Flexible covenants allow you to keep horses and chickens, perfect for a rural lifestyle. Embrace the freedom of the Hills—ideal for ATV riding, exploring nature, and experiencing scenic attractions. Seize this unique opportunity to build your dream home or develop a profitable retreat in the stunning Black Hills. Contact Anne either call or text 605-673-1177 today to learn more and schedule a viewing! $228,480 MLS#87472

Lot 10 Lonesome Dove Street, Custer
$313,600
177517 MLS
Listed by Jon Eizinger 605-484-4374 of Sun Real Estate. No covenants, no zoning and back of property line borders 587 acres of US Forest Service land! 12.20 acres of gently sloping land with excellent views, wooded with mixed trees, an aspen grove and several excellent building sites. Two separate lots for building or combine the two. Lots of wildlife, hiking, hunting, or just enjoying the quiet natural setting. Seclusion but still only minutes to downtown Custer and many Black Hills attractions.

TBD Elliot Rd, Custer
$545,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 87434 MLS
Open-concept, single-level living ranch on a lush acreage with a front row seat to US Forest Service land! "Welcome home" kitchen highlighting Rustic Alder cabinets, tile floor, pantry, and breakfast bar. Inviting dining room with sliding door to a sprawling open deck that perfectly frames hundreds of USFS acres. Striking 3/4 inch hand-scraped hickory hardwood floors stretching into the breath-of-fresh-air living room to unwind and kick your feet up, adorned with a vaulted ceiling & cozy gas fireplace. Dreamy master suite with private full bathroom. Another good-sized bedroom with a full bath. Convenient laundry with cabinets & deep sink just off of the kitchen, outside of the 2-stall attached garage. Knotty pine solid core doors & pine trim throughout. Covered front stoop & generously-sized entrance with coat closet. Horses allowed.

26020 Golden Willow Parkway, Custer
$520,000
3 Beds ⋅ 177472 MLS
Commercially zoned in downtown Custer and can be a short-term rental. This property offers multiple uses. The front area is suitable for a clinic, office, or retail, while the rear portion is suitable for short-term rentals or residential use, as approved by Custer City Code 17.20.020. It's located on the high-traffic Mount Rushmore Road/ US Highway 16A/385. It's located near hotels and restaurants with prime retail visibility. There have been numerous recent renovations, including a new kitchen, a gas fireplace, a detached garage, new windows, and a new metal roof. The porch and parking area are recently built and feature areas of stamped and decoratively stained concrete There is a Tesla Charging station in the parking area.

305 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer
$520,000
177351 MLS
Commercial building in downtown Custer. This property offers multiple uses. The front area is suitable for a clinic, office, or retail, while the rear portion is suitable for short-term rentals or residential use, as approved by Custer City Code 17.20.020. It's located on the high-traffic Mount Rushmore Road/ US Highway 16A/385. It's located near hotels and restaurants with prime retail visibility. There have been many recent renovations, including a new kitchen, gas fireplace, detached garage, windows, and a new metal roof. The porch and parking area is recently built and feature areas of stamped and decoratively stained concrete There is a Tesla Charging station in the parking area.

305 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer
$1,149,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 87322 MLS
EVERYTHING YOU WANT & MORE! Boast-worthy bonuses galore in this BRAND NEW CUSTOM BUILT HOME! Brimming with the utmost quality and fine craftsmanship. The beautifully designed exterior makes a lasting impression, while the grand great room boasts vaulted ceilings and floor-to-ceiling windows that bathe the space in natural light. The gourmet chef’s kitchen is equipped with state-of-the-art appliances, perfect for culinary enthusiasts, and features a spacious butler’s pantry. The luxurious primary suite is a private retreat tucked behind the kitchen, with a walkout to the covered patio for ultimate tranquility. Upstairs, you'll find three additional bedrooms and two more bathrooms, providing ample space for family and guests. The thoughtful floorplan includes an open loft space for quiet relaxing. The oversized 3-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles and storage. The expansive outdoor living area includes a full-length covered patio, a second covered patio, and a beautiful level yard with trees along the lot line for added privacy. There's space for everyone to enjoy in this exquisite home. Schedule your tour today and experience it for yourself!

25270 Mill Pond Estates Rd, Custer
$929,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 87230 MLS
40.2 private acres bordering 80 acres of National Forest Service land — with over 5,100 sq ft of finished and flexible space across three structures. This is the Black Hills setup buyers search for and rarely find: room for horses, a true guest cabin, a heated shop, and fiber optic internet fast enough to work from anywhere. The 3,674 sq ft main residence (4 bed, 3.5 bath) is built for the setting: soaring vaulted ceilings, cedar and pine accents, and three patio doors opening to a wrap-around deck with sweeping long-distance southern views. Two great rooms, each with a fireplace, anchor the main and walkout lower levels. The lower level lives like its own wing — an ensuite bedroom, two additional bedrooms, full bath, wet bar, and family room with propane fireplace, ideal for guests or multigenerational living. The 1,166 sq ft guest cabin with 302 sq ft loft offers real flexibility: extended family, visiting friends, or a private office/studio. The detached 1,120 sq ft heated three-bay garage includes an unfinished second-floor loft ready to become additional living space, plus RV parking. Infrastructure is done right: 450-ft freshwater well feeding three cisterns, private septic, two propane tanks, metal roof, fenced garden, and a well-maintained road with year-round access. Minutes from Custer State Park and the heart of the Black Hills, yet completely private. Horses welcome. Come see why this land can't be replicated. Call today to schedule your private showing!

11431 Wrangler Rd, Custer
$699,000
177178 MLS
Exceptional acreage offering a truly rare combination of ponds, wildlife, and unmatched Black Hills beauty. This remarkable acreage features multiple ponds nestled among mature aspens and pines, dramatic rock outcroppings, and is backed by USFS land for endless privacy and recreation. The spring-fed dam sits at the headwaters of Beaver Creek and is reported by the sellers to stay full year-round—perfect for kayaking, floating on warm summer days, and enjoying abundant wildlife including waterfowl, turtles, frogs, and annual ducklings. Fiber optics run to the lot, and major improvements are already in place, including a private well producing an impressive 32 GPM, a 400 amp, 3 wire single-phase electric meter box, 50-amp RV pedestal, and nearby hydrant. Covenants allow for vacation rentals, camping, and additional structures, making this an ideal setting for an executive or dream home with exceptional flexibility. Wildflowers blanket the property seasonally, with sellers especially noting the beauty of wild snapdragons. Purchased prior to surrounding development, the sellers were able to hand-pick the boundaries of this premier location. Properties of this caliber—especially those backed by USFS land—are extraordinarily rare. A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own one of the finest acreages in the southern Black Hills. Stunning in every season, the property truly glows in the fall when the aspens blaze with color.

12355 Star Valley Dr, Custer
$699,000
87222 MLS
Exceptional acreage offering a truly rare combination of water, wildlife, and unmatched Black Hills beauty. This remarkable acreage features multiple ponds nestled among mature aspens and pines, dramatic rock outcroppings, and is backed by USFS land for endless privacy and recreation. The spring-fed dam sits at the headwaters of Beaver Creek and is reported by the sellers to stay full year-round—perfect for floating on warm summer days, fishing and enjoying abundant wildlife including waterfowl, turtles, frogs, and annual ducklings. Fiber optics run to the lot, and major improvements are already in place, including a private well producing an impressive 32 GPM, a 400 amp, 3 wire single-phase electric meter box, 50-amp RV pedestal, and nearby hydrant. Covenants allow for vacation rentals, camping, and additional structures, making this an ideal setting for an executive or dream home with exceptional flexibility. Wildflowers blanket the property seasonally and sellers just love the dam. Purchased prior to surrounding development, the sellers were able to hand-pick the boundaries of this premier location. Properties of this caliber—especially those backed by USFS land—are extraordinarily rare. A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own one of the finest acreages in the southern Black Hills. Stunning in every season, the property truly glows in the fall when the aspens blaze with color.

12355 Star Valley Drive, Custer
$182,500
176889 MLS
Rare Three-City-Lot Opportunity with Views & Development Potential! Discover an exceptional building opportunity consisting of three combined city lots, offering privacy, dramatic granite rock outcroppings, and gorgeous city views. This grand building site previously supported two homes and now presents endless possibilities—build your dream home, explore duplex or townhome options, or hold lots for future resale (lots may be sold individually). The property includes two active city water taps (currently approximately $30/month each). City sewer is on the lot; seller has no knowledge of exact location or condition. Walk to the back of the property, turn around, and take in the stunning views that could be yours every day. Zoned within city limits with city services available and just a short jaunt to the Mickelson Trail. Seller previously explored plans for up to five townhomes—buyer to verify all development options with the city. Major potential in a prime location! Also visit with your insurance agent, lot has hydrant and often can lead to discounted rates. Corners are marked with green ribbon.

405 N 7th, Custer
$182,500
86979 MLS
Rare Three-City-Lot Opportunity with Views & Development Potential! Discover an exceptional building opportunity consisting of three combined city lots, offering privacy, dramatic granite rock outcroppings, and gorgeous city views. This grand building site previously supported two homes and now presents endless possibilities—build your dream home, explore duplex or townhome options, or hold lots for future resale (lots may be sold individually). The property includes two active city water taps (currently approximately $30/month each). City sewer is on the lot; seller has no knowledge of exact location or condition. Walk to the back of the property, turn around, and take in the stunning views that could be yours every day. Zoned within city limits with city services available and just a short jaunt to the Mickelson Trail. Seller previously explored plans for up to five townhomes—buyer to verify all development options with the city. Major potential in a prime location! Also visit with your insurance agent, lot has hydrant and often can lead to discounted rates. Corners are marked with green ribbon.

405 N 7th Street, Custer
$295,000
176797 MLS
Priced well below assessed value! If Black Hills privacy and wide-open space are on your radar, this 19.42-acre offering may be the perfect fit. Comprised of three parcels with a uniquely versatile layout, the front parcel is subject to the covenants of South Park Subdivision, while the rear 15 acres are covenant-free—offering flexibility to build freely and potentially enjoy horses or other animals. An easement is currently being finalized to provide continuous, legal access to the back parcels as well as the neighboring property to the west. With expansive views, excellent southern exposure, and ample room to create your ideal homestead, this property invites you to dream big and build boldly.

TBD South Park Dr, Custer
Start Your Search